Horace’s Odes 1, 4; 4, 7 and 4, 12 commented by Porphyrio, Pseudo-Acro, Landino and Mancinelli (Venetiis 1492)
Abstract
This work examines the commentaries on Horace’s Odes 1, 4; 4, 7 and 4, 12 composed by Porphyrio, Pseudo-Acro,Cristoforo Landino and Antonio Mancinelli (Horatius cum quatuor commentariis, Venetiis 1492). After a brief overview of the Horatian exegetical tradition, we analyze the similarities and differences in terms of content and form between ancient scholia and Renaissance commentaries. Thus, we aim to highlight the interpretations on these poems by the different exegetes and its role in a scholastic context.
References
ARCAZ POZO, J. L. (1998): «Presencia de las Odas I 4, IV 7 y IV 12 de Horacio en la Canción XVI de Diego Hurtado de Mendoza», CFC (L) 15: 171-184.
BOCCACCIO, G. (1532): Peri genealogias deororum, libri quindecim, cum annotationibus…, Jean Herwagen, Basileae.
CANTÓ LLORCA, J. (1994): «Los comentaristas antiguos de Horacio», en R. CORTÉS TOVAR - J. C. FERNÁNDEZ CORTE (eds.), Bimilenario de Horacio, Ediciones Universidad de Salamanca, Salamanca, pp. 349-357.
COMIATI, G. (2015): Horace in the Italian Renaissance (1498-1600) [Tesis Doctoral], Warwick.
COMIATI, G. (2019): «Humanistic Biographies of Horace and His Inclusion in the Fifteenth-century Literary Canon», en E. MORRA (ed.), Building the Canon through the Classics: Imitation and Variation in Renaissance Italy (1350-1580), Brill, Leiden / Boston, pp. 96-125.
COPPINI, D. (2020): «L’Orazio platonico di Cristoforo Landino», en M. LAUREYS - N. DAUVOIS - D. COPPINI (eds.), Non omnis moriar. Die Horaz-Rezeption in der neulateinischen Literatur vom 15. bis zum 17. Jahrhundert, vol. 1, Olms, Hildesheim / Zürich / New York, pp. 137-195.
CURCIO, G. (1913): Q. Orazio Flacco studiato in Italia dal secolo XIII al XVIII, Francesco Battiano, Catania.
DESPREZ, L. (1691): Quinti Horatii Flacci opera, interpretatione et notis illustravit…, vols. 1-2, Frédéric Léonard, Parisiis.
DIEDERICH, S. (1999): Der Horazkommentar des Porphyrio im Rahmen der kaiserzeitlichen Schul- und Bildungstradition, De Gruyter, Berlin / Boston.
FORMENTI, C. (2016): Il commento pseudoacroneo A’ e lo studio di Orazio nella scuola tardoantica [Tesis Doctoral], Milano.
FRIIS-JENSEN, K. (2007): «The reception of Horace in the Middle Ages», en S. HARRISON (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Horace, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 291-304.
GILSON, S. A. (2005): «Notes on the Presence of Boccaccio in Cristoforo Landino’s Comento sopra la Comedia di Danthe Alighieri», Italian Culture 23: 1-30.
GLAREANUS, H. (1536): In Q. Horatium Flaccum … annotationes …, Johann Froben, Friburgi Brisgoiae.
GRENDLER, P. F. (1989): Schooling in Renaissance Italy: Literacy and Learning, 1300-1600, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore / London.
GRIMAL, P. (19894): Diccionario de mitología griega y romana, traducción de Francisco PAYAROLS, Paidós, Barcelona [ed. original francesa, Paris, 1951].
IURILLI, A. (1996): «Il corpus oraziano fra editoria e scuole umanistiche nei secoli XV e XVI», IJCT 3.2: 147-158.
JIMÉNEZ CALVENTE, T. (2014): «Un tipo de lectura profesional: los humanistas y los textos», eHumanista 27: 329-349.
KLINGNER, F. (19593): Q. Horatii Flacci Opera. Tertium recognovit, Teubner, Lipsiae (19391).
LAMBIN, D. (1561): Q. Horatius Flaccus, Jean de Tournes, Lugduni.
LANDINO, C. (1482): Christophori Landini Florentini in Q. Horatii Flacci libros omnes…, Antonio di Bartolommeo Miscomini, Florentiae.
LONGOBARDI, C. (2011): Il corpus pseudoacroniano e l’interpretazione di Orazio [Tesis Doctoral], Napoli.
LÓPEZ-CAÑETE QUILES, D. (2019): «La fuente clásica del preámbulo al “fatigado fin y remate que tuvo
el gobierno de Sancho Panza” (Quijote II, 53)», Minerva 32: 185-209.
MACCIÒ,F. (s.f.): «Tempi dell’uomo e tempi della natura: nascita ed evoluzione di un motivo» [https://mediaclassica.loescher.it/news/tempi-dell-uomo-e-tempi-della-natura-nascita-ed-evoluzione-diun-motivo-2548].
MANCINELLI, A. (1491): Vergilius cum quinque commentis, Filippo Pinzi, Venetiis.
MANCINELLI, A. (1492): Horatius cum quatuor commentariis, Filippo Pinzi, Venetiis.
MCLELLAN, D. (2013): «Spreading the Word: Antonio Mancinelli, the Printing Press, and theTeaching of the Studia humanitatis», en J. FEROS RUYS - J. O. WARD - M. HEYWORTH (eds.), The Classics in the Medieval and Renaissance Classroom: The Role in the Arts Curriculum as Revealed by Surviving Manuscripts and Early Printed Books, Brepols, Turnhout, pp. 287-308.
MEYER, G. (1874): Pomponii Porphyrionis Commentarii in Q. Horatium Flaccum, Teubner, Lipsiae.
PÉREZ-ABADÍN BARRO, S. (2018): «La oda estacional hispano-portuguesa: secuelas horacianas y conexiones vernáculas en ‘Eis nos torna a nascer’», Bulletin of Spanish Studies 95.8: 931-955.
PIEPER, C. (2013): «Horatius Praeceptor Eloquentiae: The Ars Poetica in Cristoforo’s Landino Commentary», en K. ENENKEL, H. NELLEN (eds.), Neo-Latin Commentaries and the Management of Knowledge in the Late Middle Ages and the Early Modern Period (1400-1700), Leuven University Press, Leuven, pp. 221-240.
PIETROSANTI, P. (2014): «Commentare gli autori antichi nella Roma del Quattrocento: Antonio Mancinelli ‘Musarum interpres’ e la sua ‘lectura’ delle Odi oraziane alla Sapienza», Quaderni del Cairoli 28: 84-102. PUGLIARELLO, M. (2009): «A lezione dal grammaticus: la lettura degli auctores», Maia 61.3: 592-610.
REYNOLDS, S. (1996): Medieval Reading: Grammar, Rhetoric and the Classical Text, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
ROBERTS, M. (1995): «Interpreting Hedonism: Renaissance Commentaries on Horace’s Epicurean Odes»,
Arethusa 28.2/3: 289-307. STADELER, A. (2015): Horazrezeption in der Renaissance: Strategien der Horazkommentierung bei Cristoforo Landino und Denis Lambin, De Gruyter, Berlin / Boston.
STENUIT, B. (2011): «Horace: éditions incunables à Florence, Venise, Milan et Strasbourg», Latomus 70.3: 780-799.
TARASKIN, P. (2013a): Reading Horace’s lyric: a tenth-century annotated manuscript in the British Library (Harley 2724) [Tesis Doctoral], London.
TARASKIN, P. (2013b): «Horace scholiasts Porphyrio and ‘Acro’ in early modern printed editions (1474-1838)», Studia Aurea 7: 339-364.
TARRANT, R. (2007): «Ancient receptions of Horace», en S. HARRISON (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Horace, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 277-290.
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right to be the first publication of the work as well as license it under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with acknowledgment of authorship of the work and initial publication in this magazine.
Authors may separately establish additional agreements for the non-exclusive distribution of the version of the work published in the journal (for example, placing it in an institutional repository or publishing it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this journal.
